Analysis of structural and functional disorders in the body as a method for predicting panic attack

Introduction. Panic attacks (PAs), not infrequently occurring against the background of apparent health, are fairly common in general medical practice and can accompany many mental, somatic, and neurological diseases. Unfortunately, in current studies of characteristics of patients with PAs insufficient attention is paid to the body as a source of physical suffering. A number of studies have confirmed the effectiveness of osteopathic treatment techniques aimed at eliminating the body′s somatic dysfunctions (SDs) as well as reducing the severity and frequency of PAs up to their complete disappearance. Also, it is obvious that there is a certain connection between panic attacks and structural and functional disorders of the body. However, criteria for risk-prediction of PAs development in healthy people and patients with PAs have not been developed.
The aim of the study: to develop criteria for risk-prediction of PAs development in healthy people and patients with PAs using osteopathic techniques based on the analysis of structural and functional disorders.
Materials and methods. The study involved 123 participants aged 39,4±10,9, including 21 men (17,1 %) and 102 women (82,9 %). All patients were divided into two groups with the first group representing 73 people with panic attacks and the second group — 50 people without panic attacks. All the patients were examined using osteopathic techniques in accordance with clinical practice guidelines.
Results. Patients with PAs have a noticeably greater number of somatic dysfunctions compared to healthy people, statistically significantly differing from them (p>0,001). Despite the diversity of SDs of the body, the following SDs are more often observed in patients with PAs: local somatic dysfunctions of the upper thoracic vertebrae, upper ribs, the sphenobasilar synchondrosis (SBS) patterns, and/or SDs of cranial sutures. A combination of these dysfunctions increases the risk of panic attack development. It can be assumed that not only an external provoking factor is needed for PA development, but also the body′s proneness to it, which is expressed as a certain combination of the SDs disrupting the normal functioning of the body, and may indicated a somatopsychiatric disorder.
Conclusion. Osteopathic techniques make it possible to predict the risk of developing PAs on the basis of the identified combinations of SDs of the first and second thoracic vertebrae, the first and second ribs, SBS patterns, and/or cranial sutures, to complement generally approved methods of diagnosing panic disorder and aid in the differential diagnosis of complex clinical cases.

1. Clinical Recommendations «Panic Disorder» (approved by the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation). M.; 2024. https://base.garant.ru/410407475/ (in russ.).

2. De Jonge P., Roest A. M., Lim C. C. et al. Cross-national epidemiology of panic disorder and panic attacks in the world mental health surveys. Depression and anxiety. 2016; 33 (12): 1155–1177. https://doi.org/10.1002/da.22572

3. Dmitriev M. N. On the understanding of the essence of paroxysmal psychovegetative disorders. Epilepsia i paroksizmalnye sostoianiya. 2014; 6 (3): 61–64. https://www.epilepsia.su/jour/article/view/51/52 (in russ.).

4. Tuter N. V. Panic attacks in the structure of schizotypal disorder (clinical, neurophysiological and psychological aspects). Vestn. novykh med. tekhnologiy. 2012; 19 (4): 128–131 (in russ.).

5. Aleksandrovskiy Yu. A., Neznanov N. G. Psychiatry: Natsionalnoe ruk. (2nd ed.) M.: GEOTAR-Media; 2022 (in russ.).

6. Anikova V. V. Phenomenology of human bodily being forms in developmental and clinical psychology. Mirovaya i rossiyskaya nauka: oblasti razvitiya i innovatsiy. 2020; 106–113 (in russ.).

7. Mokhov D. E., Tregubova E. S., Potekhina Yu. P. Osteopathy and its restorative potential. St. Petersburg: Nevskiy rakurs; 2020 (in russ.).

8. Krasnoiarova N. A. Osteopathiya kak meditsina budushchego. Russ. Osteopath. J. 2017; 3–4: 66–75. https://doi.org/10.32885/2220-0975-2017-3-4-66-75 (in russ.).

9. Abaev Yu.K. Laws and categories of dialectics in medicine. Med. zhurn. 2009; 4: 146–149. https://medmag.bsmu.by/vypuski/2009-4/zakony-i-kategorii-dialektiki-v-meditsine/ (in russ.).

10. Magun G. I. Osteopathy in the cranial region. St. Petersburg: OOO «Meridian-S»; 2010 (in russ.).

11. Belyaev A. F. Fundamentals of chiropractic medicine: Klinicheskie lektsii dlya vrachey i klinicheskikh ordinatorov. Vladivostok, 1998 (in russ.).

12. Belyaev A. F. Osteopathic treatment of panic attacks in children and adolescents // In: Mezhdunarodnyy kongress «Aktualnye voprosy osteopatii». St. Petersburg; 2015 (in russ.).

13. Still E. T. Philosophy and mechanical principles of osteopathy. M.: MIK; 2015 (in russ.).

14. Li I. L. Restorative manual correction of the functional state of the body in pain syndromes in the thoracic region: Autoref. dis. kand. med. nauk: 14.00.51. M.; 2005 (in russ.).

15. Li I. L., Belyaev A. F. Method for manual diagnosis of pain syndromes in the thoracic region: Patent RF № 2302852. 20.07.2007 (in russ.).

16. Belyaev A. F., Li I. L. Effect of osteopathic techniques on autonomic regulation in patients with pain syndromes in the thoracic region // In: I Rossiyskiy sezd vrachey-osteopatov. M.; 2008: 64–65 (in russ.).

17. Ilchenko A. O., Egorova I. A., Chervotok A. E. et al. Dynamics of osteopathic status indicators during treatment in patients with panic attacks. Manual. ter. 2023; 3: 3–11. https://doi.org/10.54504/1684-6753-2022-3-11 (in russ.).

18. Lototskiy A. Yu., Krestina L. S. Application of osteopathic correction in the complex treatment of anxiety-panic disorders // Trudy Instituta osteopaticheskoy meditsiny. St. Petersburg; 2010–2015: 165–169 (in russ.).

19. Malakhovskiy V. V., Tyushina M. V. Application of osteopathic methods in the comprehensive rehabilitation of patients suffering from panic attacks with cardialgic syndrome. Manual. ter. 2014; 4: 73–75 (in russ.).

20. Adamasova Yu. V., Belash V. O. Osteopathic correction in the complex treatment of female patients with panic disorder. Russ. Osteopath. J. 2024; 4: 66–77. https://doi.org/10.32885/2220-0975-2024-4-66-77 (in russ.).

21. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-V). American Psychiatric Publishing, 2013.

22. Mokhov D. E., Belash V. O., Aptekar I. A., Nenashkina E. N., Potekhina Yu. P., Tregubova E. S., Belyaev A. F. Somatic dysfunction: Clinical guidelines. Russ. Osteopath. J. 2023; 2: 8–90. https://doi.org/10.32885/2220-0975-2023-2-8-90 (in russ.).

23. Aleksandrova A. S. Assisting students in personal development by identifying and eliminating muscular tensions to normalize emotional state during the educational process // In: Innovatsionnaya praktika v sovremennom obrazovanii: opyt, problemy, resheniya. Vserossiyskaya yarmarka pedagogicheskikh innovatsiy. Omsk: Mnogoprofi lnaya akademiya nepreryvnogo obrazovaniya; 2021: 4–13 (in russ.).

24. Kosareva D. D., Sumnaya D. B., Kinzerskiy A. A. et al. Fascial manipulations for anxiety disorders with cervical myofascial pain syndrome. Manual. ter. 2019; 3 (75): 15–25 (in russ.).

25. Kuchinskaya O. V., Shiryaeva E. E. Effect of osteopathic correction of leading regional somatic dysfunction on the functional state of the circulatory system. Russ. Osteopath. J. 2015; 3–4: 37–44. https://doi.org/10.32885/2220-0975-2015-3-4-37-44 (in russ.).

26. Vasileva L. F. Functional blocks of spinal and limb joints. LFK i massazh. 2006; 10 (34): 3–9 (in russ.).

27. Krasnoyarova N. A. Prospects of osteopathic and manual medicine in modern neurology. Vestn. Kazanskogo NMU. 2014; 2 (1): 133–138 (in russ.).

28. Birstein E., Gusky J. Fascial release therapy for panic attacks: A pilot study. J. Bodywork Movem. Ther. 2020; 24 (3): 161–164. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbmt.2020.01.002

29. Nemkova S. A., Chutko L. S. Symptoms and masks. Psychosomatic and somatopsychic disorders in children. Effektivnaya farmakoterapiya. 2019; 15 (14): 80–88 (in russ.).

30. ICD-11. Chapter 06. Mental, behavioural and neurodevelopmental disorders: statistical classifi cation / Ed. G. P. Kostiuk. M.: KDU; Universitetskaya kniga. 2021. https://doi.org/10.31453/kdu.ru.91304.0143 (in russ.).

31. Mendelevich E. G. Somatization of anxiety disorders in the practice of a neurologist: algorithms and approaches to differentiated treatment. Nevrologiya, neiropsikhiatriya, psikhosomatika. 2014; 4: 81–86 (in russ.).

32. Mokhov D. E., Potekhina Yu. P., Tregubova E. S., Gurichev A. A. Osteopathy as a new direction in medicine (modern concept of osteopathy). Russ. Osteopath. J. 2022; 2: 8–26. https://doi.org/10.32885/2220-0975-2022-2-8-26 (in russ.).